The cost of a particular thing
You notice it
with your hand.
A drawer closes without the little correction you have learned to make. A stair rail turns beneath your palm. At the window, the latch has a weight that suits the frame. These are small encounters, but you repeat them thousands of times.
A custom home gives those encounters room in the budget. It also gives you more decisions than any one person can reasonably care about equally. The useful question is where the difference will matter to you.
A line has to be built.
From across a room, a handrail is a line. Close up, it becomes a succession of pieces, grain directions and joints. Someone has to resolve the curve, make the parts, bring them to the house and fit them to the work already there.
That is one reason a restrained detail can be expensive. The finished shape does not describe the number of operations behind it. A joint concealed by trim and a joint left exposed ask different things of the people making them.
In the 2021 Super Houses conversation, Scott Hobbs explains this through a stair baluster shoe. Remove the covering at the base and the connection beneath it has to deliver the visible finish. His example concerns fabrication and assembly, not a claim that every minimal stair costs more than every decorative one.1
Choose the room
before the upgrade.
It is easy to compare two products in isolation. It is harder, and more useful, to decide what the room needs. A window might be chosen for its frame proportions, the way it opens, its thermal performance or its relationship to a stone opening. Those qualities will not necessarily improve together as the price rises.
ENERGY STAR’s window guidance distinguishes heat transfer, solar heat gain and visible light transmission. These are separate ratings. Compare the whole product, then ask the designer which performance characteristics suit that orientation and room.2
Try the actual hardware. Look through a full-size sample if one is available. Examine the meeting rails and the view when the sash is open. A technical comparison and a physical encounter answer different questions.
This also helps when a specification needs to change. If the essential quality is a narrow frame around a particular view, tell the team. If it is easy operation for a frequently used window, say that. A substitution can then be judged against the reason the product was chosen.
“If it doesn’t matter to you,
you shouldn’t spend that money.”
Scott Hobbs, Super Houses, 2021.1
Scott’s conversation includes a deliberately steep description of the cost of the last increments of refinement. It is a builder’s way of describing a tradeoff. It is not a measured quality scale or a formula for predicting a house price.
Live with the sample.
A material is more than its best photograph. Put the sample where it will be used. Look at it in morning light and under the proposed lamps. Ask what daily cleaning involves and what a spill, scratch or repair will look like.
The Natural Stone Institute distinguishes acid-sensitive calcareous stones from siliceous stones, while warning that mineral composition still matters. An impregnating sealer does not make stone stain-proof. The care routine belongs in the selection conversation.3
Some owners enjoy the marks that accumulate on a surface. Others find them irritating. Neither response needs to be dressed up as a design principle. Be honest before a material becomes a whole kitchen.
Ask for an installed sample when the junction matters: stone against metal, a cabinet edge beside plaster, or a painted finish under grazing light. The meeting of materials can be the part you notice most.
Spend unevenly.
A small bar can carry a strong color and a beautifully made cabinet without requiring every room to make the same gesture. A house benefits from places of emphasis and places of rest. The budget can follow that rhythm.
Make a short list of the details you would regret losing. Then name the ones you are comfortable simplifying. Ask the architect and builder to price alternatives that preserve the intent: perhaps a familiar material used precisely, a repeated detail instead of several bespoke ones, or fewer changes in the wall and ceiling planes.
This is different from removing necessary performance. Water management, structural requirements and safe installation need to be resolved regardless of how visible they are. Savings should come from a considered change in scope, not from leaving a necessary part of the assembly undefined.
The things you keep noticing.
A custom house costs what it costs because of its size, site, labor, systems, materials and the particular work asked of them. A high price alone does not demonstrate good judgment. Ask what each important choice buys and what it requires from the rest of the project.
For the mechanics of comparing estimates, see how to read a custom home budget. For the choices themselves, return to the room. Imagine a weekday breakfast, a hand on the stair, a window opened at the end of the afternoon. Those are useful tests of where the money should go.
Builders, since 1954.
More About Hobbs
Hobbs, Inc. has been building and renovating homes since 1954. The Journal draws on that work and on conversations with architects and craftspeople about the decisions behind a finished home.
Discover HobbsSources and conversation
For a closer look
- Hobbs Conversations: Super Houses
Scott Hobbs and Robert Cardello, April 16, 2021. Checked against the supplied full transcript. Speakers are sources, not authors; historical prices are not current allowances.
- ENERGY STAR: Independently Tested and Certified Energy Performance
Whole-product ratings describe separate aspects of thermal and daylight performance.
- Natural Stone Institute: Care and Cleaning
Stone composition, cleaning and the limits of impregnating sealers.
A few practical questions
Why can a simple custom detail be expensive?
An exposed junction may need more precise fabrication and fitting than one covered by trim. Ask the builder to explain the drawing, material and installation work behind the particular detail.
Does a higher price always mean a better window?
No single price or rating answers every need. Compare the whole-unit performance, operation, proportions, installation requirements and service arrangements for the actual room.
Where should an owner simplify a custom home?
Begin with priorities. Identify the experiences and details that matter, then ask the design team to price coherent alternatives elsewhere. Keep required safety, structure and weather protection fully resolved.
Continue reading
More from the Journal
The JournalWhat a Home Addition Costs, and What Drives It
Read the story →
The JournalBuy the Design First
Read the story →
The JournalHow 125 Employees Become 2,000 People on a Jobsite
Read the story →
The JournalRenovating a New York Apartment or Co-op to a Custom Standard
Read the story →
The JournalBuilding on the Water: Rain That Comes In Sideways
Read the story →
The JournalDesigning a Hamptons House for Light, Landscape, and Privacy
Read the story →
The JournalA Gut Renovation in New York, Done to a Custom Standard
Read the story →
The JournalWhat a Staircase Actually Costs, and Why
Read the story →
The JournalThe Things You Only Notice If You Live There
Read the story →
The JournalRenovate or Tear Down: The Question Every Hamptons Owner Asks
Read the story →
The JournalA Kitchen Renovation, Built Like the Rest of the House
Read the story →
The JournalThe quiet work of a comfortable home
Read the story →
The JournalAdding to the house you already love
Read the story →
The JournalNYC Townhouse and Brownstone Renovation
Read the story →
The JournalChoosing windows: beyond standard and custom
Read the story →
The JournalThe Pool House, Built to the Standard of the Main House
Read the story →
The JournalBefore the room comes together
Read the story →
The JournalLuxury home finishes, up close
Read the story →
The JournalRooms for a good evening
Read the story →
The JournalA home at the edge of the Sound
Read the story →
The JournalRenovating an antique home: what deserves to stay
Read the story →
The JournalA home with room for the next generation
Read the story →The Hobbs Journal
New stories, by email.
Writing on architecture, materials and the work of building a home. Subscribe for new Journal articles and conversations from Hobbs.