
Craft / Structure / Cost
The smallest piece can change the whole estimate.
Look at the point where a baluster meets a stair tread. There may be a small collar there, called a shoe. It is easy to overlook in a photograph. Remove it from the drawing, though, and the fabricator has a different job.
In a conversation with architect Robert Cardello, Scott Hobbs uses that detail to explain why a visually simpler staircase can cost more. The shoe covered the connection. Without it, the fit underneath has to stand on its own.1
01 / At the connection
What the shoe was hiding
For the stair detail Scott describes, omitting the shoe leaves the work needing to be “dead nuts perfect.” His point is about fabrication and assembly. A connection that once had some visual forgiveness now needs a carefully resolved finish.
That affects the drawing, the drilling, the order in which pieces go together and the work done on site. The fabricator needs to resolve how the exposed connection will be made and assembled.
Detail study / Select a condition
The shoe covers the junction between baluster and tread.
This is a conceptual detail study, not a construction drawing. Connection geometry and concealed fixings vary by design.02 / Around the curve
A curve asks more of every part.
A curved stair brings the treads, balusters and rail into a changing geometry. The inside and outside edges travel different distances. Repeating details have to be laid out so they read coherently along the flight, and the handrail has to arrive cleanly at its transitions.
Scott describes wanting the pieces to “line up in a way that all makes sense.” That is an aesthetic judgment made through measurements, shop drawings and fitted parts. The rail cannot be considered separately from the stair it follows.
The Architectural Woodwork Institute treats wood stairs, handrails and guards as a coordinated fabrication and installation subject. For a custom stair, it is worth establishing the intended quality and scope in the specifications before comparing estimates.2

03 / In the plan
“a little sculptural element in the plan.”Robert Cardello, on the staircase
Cardello sees the stair as an opportunity to organize the house. Moving it from a center hall to an outside wall, he says, “opens up all these floor plan opportunities.” The stair can become part of the experience of the rooms around it.
Its footprint is decided early. Floor-to-floor height, the number of risers, tread depth, landings and headroom all compete for space. A stair that feels generous to walk needs room in the plan, not just a more generous finish allowance.
Precision has more than one measure.
Scott’s remark that an inspector can fail a stair “for a quarter inch off” conveys how exacting the work can be. It is not a universal tolerance for every stair dimension. Riser uniformity, handrail height, openings and headroom are different requirements.
For example, the 2021 International Residential Code permits no more than a ⅜-inch difference between the greatest and smallest riser height within a flight. That is a model-code provision, not a substitute for the code adopted where the house is being built.3
The drawings need to resolve the applicable requirements alongside the finished floor levels. A change in floor buildup can affect the first or last step, even when the stair itself has not changed.
Before the estimate
Price the stair that will actually be built.
Geometry
Agree on the flight, turns, landings and relationship to the surrounding rooms. These decisions establish the work the stair must do.
Connections
Show the tread, baluster and rail junctions. Identify which are concealed and which will remain exposed.
Scope
Confirm what fabrication, finish, delivery and installation include. Two estimates are useful only when they describe the same stair.
The useful budget conversation begins with those drawings. It gives the architect, builder and fabricator something specific to discuss before a detail becomes an expensive surprise.
Builders, since 1954.
More About Hobbs
Hobbs, Inc. has been building and renovating homes since 1954. The Journal draws on that work and on conversations with architects and craftspeople about the decisions behind a finished home.
Discover HobbsSources and conversation
For a closer look
- Hobbs Conversations: Super Houses
Scott Hobbs and architect Robert Cardello, Boroughs and Burbs, April 16, 2021. The observations and quotations in this feature come from that conversation.
- Architectural Woodwork Institute: Wood Stair, Handrail, and Guard Systems
Industry framework for wood stair fabrication and installation. Project specifications determine which requirements apply.
- International Code Council: 2021 IRC, R311.7.5.1
Model-code reference for riser height and uniformity. The adopted local code, amendments and building type govern a particular project.
A few practical questions
What makes a custom staircase expensive?
The shape of the stair, the materials and the connections all affect the work. Curves and exposed joints can require more drawing, fabrication and fitting. An estimate should cover the finish, delivery and installation as well as the stair itself.
When should the stair design be finalized?
Resolve its location and geometry while the floor plan is being developed. Before fabrication, coordinate the shop drawings with the structure, finished floor levels and applicable code requirements.
Does a simpler staircase cost less?
It can, but fewer visible parts do not always mean less work. Removing a baluster shoe leaves the junction with the tread exposed. The fabrication and installation then have to deliver the finish that the shoe would have concealed.
The Hobbs Journal
New stories, by email.
Writing on architecture, materials and the work of building a home. Subscribe for new Journal articles and conversations from Hobbs.
















