
Apartment and co-op renovation
The apartment ends at the door.
The renovation does not.
Imagine the stone for a kitchen island arriving at the service entrance. The slab fits the room upstairs. Does it fit the elevator? Can it make the turn from the cab into the corridor? Where can it wait while another resident’s delivery comes through?
That journey is part of an apartment renovation. So are the pipes that continue through your ceiling, the people living below your bathroom and the building staff who manage a working day around everyone else’s home.
The finished rooms should feel personal. Getting there requires understanding a building you share. A good starting point is a set of drawings and a conversation with the managing agent, before the plan depends on changes the building may not allow.


“may take a lot more time than the actual city.”Scott Hobbs, discussing co-op review
Two approvals, different questions.
In The Current Market, Scott describes the time co-op review can take. His observation is a reason to put building review on the schedule from the beginning.1
The building’s approval and the city’s permits do different jobs. A board and its reviewing professionals consider the proposed alteration against the building’s requirements. The city evaluates the work under the applicable regulations. Neither approval should be treated as a substitute for the other.
Ask the managing agent for the current alteration agreement, submission requirements and house rules. Review them with the architect and builder. Confirm who will answer review comments, how revised drawings are submitted and what must be in place before work can begin.
The city does exempt certain minor repairs from permits. More substantial alterations can require filed plans and separate trade permits. The scope of the work determines the route, so “just renovating the kitchen” is not enough information to settle it.2

The building has a floor plan of its own.
Your plan shows rooms. The building has another arrangement to contend with: structure, risers, shafts, drains and routes for maintenance. Those systems can narrow the choices for a new bathroom, a kitchen or air conditioning.
A plumbing chase that looks inconvenient on a sketch may serve apartments above and below. Before deciding that it can disappear, have the team establish what it contains and how it can be accessed. Keep the same question in mind when enclosing equipment in millwork. A beautifully fitted panel still needs a way to come off.
Architect Robert Cardello describes the difficulty of recording an existing house in Super Houses. Send two people to measure it, he says, and you will get “two different sets of drawings back.” His point is the judgment involved in documenting a renovation, where the building already exists and its conditions have to be understood.6
A section through the kitchen ceiling, for example, can help the team resolve ductwork, lighting and cabinet height together. Ask which dimensions have been verified and which remain assumptions before those drawings are used for fabrication.
From curb to room
Follow one delivery all the way in.
Choose a difficult piece early: a long cabinet, a large appliance or a slab of stone. Walk its actual route with the team. Each stop raises a different question.
The street
Where can the vehicle unload? Who receives it? Confirm the delivery window before the supplier commits to a time.
The service entrance
Measure openings and turns. Agree on protection, building access and the point at which responsibility for the delivery changes hands.
The elevator
Check the cab, door and permitted load with building management. A piece that fits inside the cab may still be impossible to turn into it.
The apartment
Decide where the piece will be stored and what work must be complete before it arrives. Delivery should follow the installation sequence.
An empty apartment can still be an occupied-building project.
Moving out does not empty the floors around you. Noise, dust, debris removal and interruptions to shared services need a plan that accounts for the other residents.
DOB’s Tenant Protection Plan guidance addresses maintained exits, fire safety, dust control, noise and essential services in occupied buildings. The project team should establish the applicable requirements and organize the work accordingly.4
The city generally allows residential construction between 7 a.m. and 6 p.m. on weekdays; work outside permitted hours requires the relevant authorization. That does not mean a co-op gives its contractors the same full working day. Confirm the building’s own hours, noisy-work restrictions and any seasonal limits.5
When you interview a contractor, ask who speaks to the superintendent, who arranges a shutdown and how the team handles a delivery that misses its slot. These are practical questions about the people who will run your project.
Buying the apartment next door
The opening is only part of the combination.
Two adjoining apartments can seem like a simple answer to needing more room. The connection deserves a feasibility study before the purchase depends on it. Consider the structure, the resulting room arrangement, light and air, exits and the treatment of the second kitchen.
DOB’s published guidance describes circumstances in which combining apartments does not require a new or amended Certificate of Occupancy. It is a conditional route, not a blanket exemption from review or permits. Have the architect confirm which rules apply to the proposed combination.3
There is also a design test: does the combined home work as one place? Walk the proposed route from the entrance to the living room, from the bedrooms to the kitchen, and from the laundry to storage. Joining two plans can leave an awkward middle. The drawing should resolve it before the wall comes out.


The details you will live with.
In an apartment, a small misalignment can sit directly in your line of sight every day. Lay out the cabinet fronts, wall panels, switches and grilles together. Review the junction between a new floor and an existing threshold. Check what happens when a door opens fully.
A sample is most useful at the point where two materials meet. Ask to see the edge of the stone against the cabinet, or the panel beside the adjacent wall finish. This gives the architect, designer and trades a common detail to work toward.
Before move-in, walk the rooms with the team. Operate the doors, drawers, lighting and equipment. Gather the required completion documents, product information and maintenance instructions. The building’s closeout requirements belong on that list too.
For an overview of Hobbs’s work in apartments and houses across the city, visit Hobbs in New York City.
Builders, since 1954.
More About Hobbs
Hobbs, Inc. has been building and renovating homes since 1954. The Journal draws on that work and on conversations with architects and craftspeople about the decisions behind a finished home.
Discover HobbsSources and conversation
For a closer look
- Hobbs Conversations: The Current Market
Boroughs and Burbs, episode 33, November 11, 2021.
- NYC DOB: Residential project requirements
Permit exemptions, registered design professionals and separate trade requirements.
- NYC DOB: Combining apartments
2016 Code Notes. Useful background on combinations and conditions for the Certificate of Occupancy exception. The architect should confirm the current filing path.
- NYC DOB: Tenant Protection Plans
Protection of residents, exits and essential services in occupied buildings.
- NYC311: Noise from construction
City construction hours and after-hours authorization. Building work rules must also be checked.
- Hobbs Conversations: Super Houses
Boroughs and Burbs, episode 23. Robert Cardello on documenting existing buildings.
A few practical questions
Do co-op and condo renovations follow the same rules?
Both can have building review and alteration requirements, but the documents and restrictions vary. Obtain the current requirements from the managing agent for the particular building.
Can I move my kitchen or bathroom?
Ask the architect to test the proposal against the building’s rules, existing plumbing and ventilation, structure and applicable requirements. A desirable location on the plan is not proof that the move is feasible.
Can I combine two apartments without changing the Certificate of Occupancy?
Some combinations qualify for that route under DOB guidance. It depends on the scope and conditions. The architect should verify eligibility and the current application requirements before you rely on it.
The Hobbs Journal
New stories, by email.
Writing on architecture, materials and the work of building a home. Subscribe for new Journal articles and conversations from Hobbs.
















