
Demolition is the first visible change.
A great deal should be decided before it.
A stripped room has a peculiar appeal. The old kitchen is gone, the partitions are open and, for a moment, almost anything seems possible. Then a pipe appears where the new doorway was meant to go. A floor needs more work than expected. The ceiling has less space for equipment than the drawings assumed.
A gut renovation gives the team access to things that smaller projects leave untouched. It also exposes the difference between what was assumed and what is there. The quality of the project depends on how those discoveries are investigated, priced and resolved.
For an owner, the useful question is what the team needs to know before committing to each next step.

The finished room gives little away.
Before the first day on site
Define what “gut” includes.
The word can describe very different jobs. One owner means replacing finishes and moving partitions. Another means new mechanical systems, structural changes and a different way of moving through the entire home. A price attached to the word alone is difficult to compare.
Start with an inventory of what stays, what goes and what needs investigation. Identify windows, floors, doors, fixtures or decorative work to retain. Decide whether something is protected in place, removed for storage or sent for restoration. Photograph it before the work begins.
On Home 2.0, Scott Hobbs describes a familiar disappointment: an owner develops a house around one budget, then receives bids at a much higher level. He favors bringing the design and construction people together early, while the owner can still decide whether to change the budget or the design. The episode concerns the Hamptons, but the collaboration he describes is relevant to a renovation brief in the city too.7
The architect develops the design and filing strategy. Early construction input can test access, sequencing and procurement alongside it. Before releasing a large assembly for fabrication, establish how it will reach the room.
What is inside the wall?
A measured survey records the space you can see. A targeted investigation addresses the conditions that the design depends on. Ask the team where an opening or other investigation would reduce an important uncertainty, and what permissions and precautions are needed first.
Hazardous-material requirements belong before disturbance. DOB identifies asbestos assessment and certification requirements for renovation work, subject to the stated exemptions. A later construction date does not authorize disturbing known asbestos-containing material.2
For pre-1978 housing, EPA’s consumer guidance explains the risk of lead dust from renovation and recommends a lead-safe certified contractor. Lead and asbestos are separate questions; solving one does not resolve the other.3
Even a careful investigation cannot reveal everything. Keep a record of unresolved conditions and agree on how discoveries will be reported, evaluated and authorized. A contingency is easier to discuss when everyone knows which uncertainties it is intended to cover.

“willing to delay gratification for two to four years.”Scott Hobbs, in The Current Market
Scott made that comment in November 2021, while discussing a busy market and extended lead times. It should not be read as a current duration for every NYC renovation. The useful point is to count the full undertaking: assembling the team, developing the design, obtaining approvals, procuring materials, building and closing out the work.1
Ask for a project-specific schedule with its assumptions visible. Which activities can overlap? Which depend on an approval, a decision or a delivery? Which dates are firm, and which are allowances? A single promised move-in date cannot answer those questions.
A decision sequence
Read the schedule through its dependencies.
Select a point in the work to see what needs to be resolved. These are planning prompts, not a duration calculator.
Permission, protection and a defined scope
Confirm required approvals and permits, hazardous-material requirements, protection of retained work and occupied areas, and the route for removing debris. Record unresolved conditions before starting.
Ask: what are we still assuming about the existing building?
Establish the approval path.
Establish the required reviews for the actual property. An apartment may need building approval as well as city permits. A designated landmark or a building in a historic district can involve LPC. Not every building in the city is landmarked.
At designated properties, LPC identifies several circumstances requiring interior-work permits, including work requiring a DOB permit, work affecting the exterior and work within a designated interior landmark. Ask the architect to identify the relevant route before treating an interior renovation as exempt.4
Keep the drawings coordinated as comments arrive. A revision accepted by one reviewer may affect another submission or a fabrication package. Someone needs to maintain the current set and make sure the people pricing and building the work are using it.

The room takes shape before the finishes arrive.
Once the rough work is in, you can see where the systems compete for space. This is the moment to resolve a grille in a paneled wall, a light that conflicts with a duct, or an access panel that lands behind a cabinet.
Have the team identify the inspections, testing and coordination reviews required before work is covered. Photograph concealed routes and retain the records. Photographs are useful for future maintenance, although they do not replace required inspections.
Discuss finished levels across adjoining rooms. Floor assemblies, stone thicknesses and thresholds can affect door clearances and transitions. These decisions need to agree with the details being fabricated elsewhere.

Budget for the whole period of being without the home.
Construction is one part of the owner’s commitment. Design and consultant fees, filing and review costs, insurance, storage and temporary accommodation may sit outside the construction contract. So may some purchases that the owner makes directly.
Read estimates against a common scope. Identify allowances, exclusions and who is supplying each item. Ask how the contingency is held and how changes are authorized. A lower initial total can reflect omitted work as readily as a more economical solution.
The same discipline applies to time. If a selection is due on Friday, know which purchase or drawing waits for it. A decision log with an owner and a due date is more useful than a general request to choose everything quickly.

Finished, tested, documented.
The last stretch is more than touching up paint. Operate the equipment and controls, review the punch list and collect warranties, maintenance information and final documentation. Ask the team to distinguish what is complete from what remains open.
DOB distinguishes a Certificate of Occupancy from other completion documents. A new or amended CO may be required for changes in use, egress or occupancy; some alterations close out with a Letter of Completion. The applicable path should have been identified earlier in the project.5
The handover should explain the home you have received. Where are the shutoffs? How are filters changed? What can be serviced without dismantling finished work? Those answers matter after the contractors have left.
Builders, since 1954.
More About Hobbs
Hobbs, Inc. has been building and renovating homes since 1954. The Journal draws on that work and on conversations with architects and craftspeople about the decisions behind a finished home.
Discover HobbsSources and conversation
For a closer look
- Hobbs Conversations: The Current Market
Boroughs and Burbs, episode 33, November 11, 2021.
- NYC DOB: Asbestos requirements
Assessment and certification requirements, including exemptions. The project scope and building conditions govern.
- U.S. EPA: Lead-safe renovation
Consumer guidance on renovation in pre-1978 homes and lead-safe certified contractors.
- NYC LPC: Permits and interior work
When work at designated properties requires LPC review, including interior alterations.
- NYC DOB: Certificate of Occupancy
Legal use, changes in occupancy or egress, Letters of Completion and older buildings.
- NYC DOB: Residential project requirements
Design professionals, permitted work and coordination of trade applications.
- Home 2.0: Renovating in the Hamptons
13:43 to 14:51. Scott Hobbs on bringing the owner, designers and builder together early. The episode concerns the Hamptons.
- Hobbs Conversations: The Current Market, procurement discussion
Episode 33, November 11, 2021, chapter 22: Drawer Slides. Scott Hobbs’s account of cabinets awaiting hardware describes conditions at that time.
A few practical questions
Does a gut renovation mean removing every existing element?
No single scope is established by that phrase. The drawings and specifications should identify retained elements, removals, new work and any investigations still required.
How long will a NYC gut renovation take?
The answer depends on the property, scope, review process, procurement and construction sequence. Ask for a project-specific schedule that separates those activities and shows the assumptions behind the move-in date.
Should the builder be involved before the design is complete?
Early construction input can help the design team test cost, access and sequencing. The architect remains responsible for the design and applicable filings; roles and appointments should be agreed for the project.
The Hobbs Journal
New stories, by email.
Writing on architecture, materials and the work of building a home. Subscribe for new Journal articles and conversations from Hobbs.
















