Conversations · MORE Network

Renovating in the Hamptons, Part II

Scott Hobbs returns to Home 2.0 on the Brown Harris Stevens MORE Network for part two, on what luxury buyers want and what it costs to build on the East End.

Home 2.0  ·  Hosted by the Hamptons Privé Team  ·  Brown Harris Stevens · MORE Network
Scott Hobbs on Home 2.0, Renovating in the Hamptons Part II Watch · 24 min
The Conversation

A Hamptons builder on what luxury buyers want, and what it costs

Scott Hobbs returned to the Hamptons Privé Team on Home 2.0, again at a Bridgehampton listing, for the second half of their conversation. Where part one weighed renovating against tearing down, part two turns to the question every owner asks first: what it costs to build in the Hamptons, and where that money actually goes. Traditional new construction runs about $800 to $1,000 a square foot, a renovation can land closer to $600 and still produce a very nice house, and modern tends to cost more than traditional for reasons that are structural, not decorative.

Scott’s point is that the headline number hides most of the truth. People do not even agree on what a square foot is, so two builders can quote the same house very differently. The window package alone can swing from $250,000 to $1 million, for windows that are not the same windows. And the one thing not to compromise, after the design, is the mechanical system, where a cheap bid usually means the wrong equipment and the wrong number of zones. The throughline, as in part one, is judgment: know what you are buying before you price it.

Key Takeaways

What luxury buyers want, and what it costs

01

Cost per square foot: traditional new construction runs about $800 to $1,000. A renovation can come in near $600 and still be a very nice house.

02

Modern costs more than traditional. More glass, a steel structure behind it, and tolerances near zero, because a modern house has to be perfect, with no place to hide.

03

Agree on what a square foot is first. Hobbs counts the first two finished floors in full, and porches, lower levels, and third floors as fractions, since each still costs something.

04

The window package is a massive delta. The same house can carry a $250,000 package or a $1 million one, and they are not the same windows.

05

Do not compromise on design, and after that, on HVAC. A cheap mechanical bid often means the wrong equipment, the wrong zones, and an expensive fix later.

06

Land value drives house size. On a high value lot, setbacks and the buildable box can push toward a larger or more modern house than first pictured.

Questions Scott Answered

The cost of building in the Hamptons, in short

What does it cost to build a custom home in the Hamptons?

Traditional new construction runs roughly $800 to $1,000 a square foot, with no real ceiling, while a renovation can land closer to $600 and still deliver a very nice house. Modern homes tend to cost more than traditional. The right figure depends on the house and the site. See the Hamptons work or how we work.

Why does a modern home cost more than a traditional one?

More glass, and glass costs more than a wood wall. The glass is usually not structural, so it needs a steel infrastructure behind it, and tolerances drop to almost zero, because a modern structure has to be perfect. Browse completed projects.

Why do square foot prices vary so much between builders?

Because people do not agree on what a square foot is. Hobbs counts the first two finished floors in full and treats porches, lower levels, and third floors as fractions, since they still cost something. Two builders can quote the same house very differently. Start with a conversation.

How much does the window package affect the budget?

A great deal. The same home can carry a $250,000 window package or a $1 million one, and they are not the same windows. The difference is the caliber of the glass, the sizes of the styles and rails, and the glazing. If you love the touch and feel at the window, spend more; if you only love the view outside, you can spend less. See the Hamptons portfolio.


Stay in the conversation

More from the East End

New conversations on renovating and building in the Hamptons, and each new Journal entry, delivered as it publishes.

Working on a home of your own? Start a conversation.


Produced by Brown Harris Stevens for the MORE Network.